Filmmakers chronicle challenges of autism

by Molly Walsh
Free Press Staff Writer
Published: Thursday, September 15, 2005


When Burlington filmmaker Anne Barbano approached Vermont families to interview them about the experience of raising a child with autism, she was traveling on familiar ground.

Barbano's 9-year-old son Nicholas was diagnosed with autism five years ago.
Though the diagnosis gave a name to the mysterious problems that Nicholas began exhibiting as a toddler, this comfort was short-lived. Barbano and her husband, Michael George, learned from doctors and research studies that autism has no cure and that symptoms can range from mild to severely debilitating.

With intensive speech therapy and other treatment, some children with autism overcome communication problems and live independent, productive lives as adults; but as Barbano and her husband discovered, finding good treatment and the money to pay for it are enormous challenges.

"It's like having a prescription but no one can fill it," Barbano said.

The difficulty of family life with autism is portrayed vividly in Barbano's new film, "Living the Autism Maze," set to be screened Saturday at 5:45 p.m. at Merrill's Roxy Cinemas in downtown Burlington. The 40-minute documentary, co-directed by Middlesex filmmaker Jeff Farber, takes viewers into the lives of Barbano's and five other Vermont families with autistic children. The parents share their frustrations with doctors and school administrators and acknowledge their big fears: What will happen when my autistic child becomes an adult?

"We're all terribly frightened for the future, for our kid's future," George says in the film.

The film touches on the raging debate about the causes of autism -- which have not been conclusively identified -- and the bitterness some parents feel after a diagnosis is made.

Doreen Giannelli of Essex Junction describes in the film how she felt after learning her pre-school daughter Darby has autism. "Our daughter has a medical condition and a medical diagnosis for which there is no medical treatment. And in my mind, once Darby was diagnosed, the medical community pretty much said. 'OK, 'bye."

Autism is a neurological disorder that affects about one in 250 births, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Symptoms include delayed or absent language, cognitive delays, repetitive body movements and limited ability to understand social rules.

The cause is unknown. Heredity and problems in pregnancy or delivery may be a cause. Also debated: whether childhood vaccines with traces of mercury are a factor.

As autism diagnoses increase, more schools are teaching children with the disorder. Most are entitled to special education services that typically exceed average per-pupil costs. In Vermont, schools spend upward of $150,000 per child or more annually on children with the most severe cases of autism, according to the Vermont Education Department.

"Maze" suggests that despite considerable expenditures by schools, many parents aren't happy with the result. Parents talk in the film about poorly coordinated programs, educators and therapists with no training in autism, and bad advice.

One of the families in the film pulled their son out of the school in favor of home schooling. Another family described how their son -- a college graduate now working as a computer programmer -- was kept off the honor roll because he couldn't pass gym and was tagged early on as unlikely to graduate. "It seems to me there's probably a lot of money spent without a lot of results," Farber said.

The film also suggests that for children with more severe needs, success does not come easily. Lisa Lawlor of Woodstock describes on camera the intensive therapies and treatment required to help her school-age autistic twin sons learn basic skills. It took four months for the boys to learn to sit in a chair at school. They could not speak until age 6. "Not a word -- nothing," Lawlor says in the film.

Barbano is relatively happy with the services her son receives. Nicholas is in third grade at Edmunds Elementary school in Burlington. He's assigned to a regular classroom, but attended by an aide throughout the school day. He receives one hour of occupational therapy and three sessions of speech therapy a week. Medicaid covers up to 26 hours a week of personal care, during which an aide works with Nicholas at home.

Even with access to special services, there are many challenges. Barbano recently visited her son's classroom to talk with his fellow students about autism and give them more insight into Nicholas. Sometimes he grabs for other children's snacks. Barbano explained that she doesn't want him to do this, but that he might not be aware that the food belongs to another child. Her goal during the chat: "Let's try to understand where he's coming from."

Barbano said the film is in some ways an SOS from families who are struggling to help children with a difficult disability. She's convinced that society can do better by families, and that someday autism will be defeated.

"I'm really waiting for the cure," Barbano said. "I think that's what helps me get up in the morning."


 

Read "Flick Chick" by Susan Green

Seven Days

Read "Benefit Screening at the Savoy Theatre"

THE WORLD online

Read Movie Review by Adele Tilton

about.com

 

 

Click on image to watch trailer


Get free Quicktime Player


Links to other Sites

Autism Support Daily

AAWARE

Vermont Family Network


 

 

Home | Bios | Testimonials | Articles | World Premiere | Upcoming Events | Buy Copies | Contact
  Living the Autism Maze 2005/ Site designed by Nick Malutama